Beware, Oblivious Minds!
This Nation’s Wallet You May Empty, But Never Its Memory!
The people are cornered.
Cornered, yes—but financially.
There’s no money left in their pockets.
Pensioners’ salaries fall short.
Workers’ hard-earned wages barely last the month.
Youths worry about their futures.
At home, the struggle to make ends meet; on the streets, talk of rising costs of living.
It’s true.
This nation is weary.
You may empty this nation’s pockets, but you cannot empty its memory!
Because there are places this people cannot be cornered.
- They have oaths.
- They have memories.
- They have shared pain.
- They have common families.
- They have shared tables.
- They have a collective fate.
- They have a collective memory.
- They have values that are never up for negotiation.
- And when necessary, they have paid the price for those values.
A New Sensitivity Every Day
Not a day passes without some societal value being reopened for debate.
One day religion.
Another day the Republic.
Another day Atatürk.
Nationalism one day.
Kurdish identity another.
The flag, too.
And that’s not all…
Even sensitivities among sports club supporters come under scrutiny.
Islamists, nationalists, Kemalists, Kurds—everyone’s values are debated separately.
Sometimes the agenda becomes so charged that one can’t help but ask:
Is this society’s reaction to words, symbols, and values being measured?
Or have we begun turning every debate into an identity issue?
Because there is a sociological truth here.
People do not live by economic interests alone. They live through their sense of belonging, memories, beliefs, and shared symbols.
Sociologist Émile Durkheim’s work on social solidarity reminds us that society is not merely the sum of individuals living in the same geography. It is the shared values and relationships that bind them which form the foundation of social life.
Therefore, analyzing a society’s economic hardships alone cannot explain all its behaviors.
You can read the wallet.
But you must also read the memory.
Those Who Do Not Know the Turkish Nation…
As the saying goes…
If they truly knew, these calculations wouldn’t hold.
So, could there be external manipulation behind these debates?
Do we have concrete evidence of such interference?
No.
Therefore, presenting an unproven possibility as fact is not journalism.
But we do have the right to ask another question.
How well can those who see Turkey only through economic indicators, political tensions, and social media reactions understand the true fabric of this society?
Because the people living on these lands share a common history.
They share common pain.
They have different beliefs, identities, and life stories.
But they also grew up on the same streets, sat at the same tables, and helped each other in disasters.
Turkey’s social fabric is not made up solely of divisions.
It is also formed by the experience of living together.
That is why, to understand society, one must look not only at points of division but also at where unity is possible.
And most importantly…
Everyone Is Aware of What’s Happening!
Don’t think people don’t see these debates.
They see.
They listen.
They watch who says what, when issues arise, and which words spark which debates.
Not every silence is acceptance.
Not every quietness is ignorance.
Sometimes people don’t speak.
But they do not forget.
Mistaking this nation’s silence for naivety is one of the greatest miscalculations possible.
Moreover, societal silence does not always mean the same thing.
- Some fall silent because they are tired.
- Some find the debate unnecessary.
- Some wait for the right moment to express their views.
- Some defend the right to express opinions they do not agree with.
This is why we cannot fit society into a single reaction, thought, or mold.
So, I am a hippie, living a dark-bohemian life. How is it that I am seen as a so-called fascist?
Because I have added personal motifs to the philosophy I believe in.
Perhaps out of respect for the people I live among and owe so much to.
As the saying goes…
“I have eaten their bread; I cannot betray.”
This is a motif.
My stance is simply that of not acting ungratefully and defending this nation’s collective memory as a writer and thinker.
I know well and believe that…
Next Up!
This time, the stage belongs to Haluk Bilginer.
A towering actor.
” alt=”Famous Turkish artist Haluk Bilginer, whose 2014 interview remark 'Why should my existence be dedicated to Turkish existence?' resurfaced in 2026, again drawing criticism.” />
In theater, cinema, television…
An artist whose international successes are a source of pride.
No criticism of his acting.
But acting is one thing…
Words that touch the collective memory of society are another.
We are revisiting an interview published on December 2, 2014.
Nearly twelve years have passed.
So why are these words back in our discourse?
More importantly…
Isn’t the context in which a statement is revived as important as the date it was originally said?
In his interview with OT magazine, Bilginer questions the “Andımız” (Student Oath).
He asks:
“Why should my existence be dedicated to Turkish existence?”
Is he wrong?
Not necessarily.
A person may want to have agency over their own existence.
They may question a child reciting an oath whose meaning they have yet to grasp.
Bilginer’s objection particularly concerns young children being made to say such an oath.
Ignoring this would mean presenting the statement out of context.
Thinking, questioning, and criticizing are everyone’s rights.
So far, no problem.
But…
Can we evaluate a sentence solely by its words?
Especially when that sentence is etched into the collective memory of millions?
The dictionary meaning of a statement and the historical meaning a society assigns to it are not always the same.
This is the issue I emphasize.
Bilginer has the right to explain his thoughts.
Those who disagree have the right to criticize.
But when bringing a sentence said years ago into today’s debates, one must recall both the full statement and the conditions of the time.
Because discussing an idea is one thing…
Presenting it as a challenge stripped of its context is another!
Law evaluates expressions of thought by its own criteria.
Society interprets the same words through historical and emotional accumulation.
We must be able to discuss these two realms separately.
There Is Also a Story Behind That Statement
“May my existence be dedicated to Turkish existence.”
This is no ordinary sentence.
It is a schoolyard of a generation.
Morning frost.
A white collar.
A black apron.
Children lined up side by side.
And a voice that remains in memories years later.
Of course, not everyone may assign the same meaning.
Some recall Atatürk.
A leader who devoted his life to the nation’s independence.
Some recall the battlefronts.
Those who left never to return.
Those who risked their lives for their nation and homeland.
Those who left home one morning and never came back.
Those who dedicated their existence to the country’s future with their pen, knowledge, and effort.
Some object.
“To whom and by what right do you dedicate the life God gave?” they ask.
That is possible.
All of these are open for discussion.
They should be discussed.
Because freedom of thought is not only about protecting views similar to our own.
But questioning a society’s collective memory is one thing; disregarding the meanings it carries is another.
Here we encounter an important sociological concept.
Collective memory.
Sociologist Maurice Halbwachs is known for his work demonstrating that individual memory is not independent of social relations.
A person does not only remember their own experiences.
They carry in their memory what their family has told them…
>
What they learned at school…
>
Events experienced collectively by society…
>
Symbols passed down through generations.
That is why a sentence one person finds ordinary may be part of another’s childhood, family, or historical belonging.
Without understanding a society’s memory, it is impossible to understand its reactions.
But the reverse is also true.
The value a statement holds for a society does not mean it cannot be criticized.
Respect for collective memory and freedom of thought are not enemies.
They can coexist.
Provided the aim of debate is not to silence each other but to understand.
Beware, Oblivious Minds!
Do not mistake this nation’s fatigue for surrender.
Do not mistake financial hardship for loss of identity.
Do not mistake silence for forgetfulness.
People here argue with each other.
They fall out over politics.
They quarrel over football.
Their beliefs, thoughts, and lifestyles differ.
But what good does it do to keep pouring fuel on these differences?
The most dangerous aspect of social polarization is when people begin judging each other not by their ideas but by their identities.
People are judged by who they are rather than what they say.
Ideas are questioned based on which side they come from.
And in the end…
Debates are carried out between identities, not ideas.
Then society talks but does not listen.
It reacts but does not try to understand.
Social media can amplify this tension.
A sentence said years ago can resurface with a few seconds of footage.
The historical context is lost.
The background is lost.
Only reaction remains.
Journalism’s responsibility is to present context before amplifying reactions.
Therefore, the questions should not only be “Who said what?”
But also “When was it said?”
“In what context was it said?”
“Why is it being discussed again today?”
Because sometimes…
Between the dictionary meaning of a sentence and the meaning a nation assigns to it lies an entire history.
If you ignore that history, you explain words but fail to understand people.
Applause Is One Thing, Justification Another
There is no harm in applauding Haluk Bilginer’s art.
Indeed, let us applaud.
Let us acknowledge his achievements.
But applauding an artist does not mean we must applaud every thought they express.
Fame does not equal being right.
Being a great actor does not mean having the final word on every issue.
And of course…
Objecting to a thought is not silencing the person who expressed it.
My objection is not to an artist’s right to express opinions.
It is about how that thought resonates in society’s memory and how it is debated today.
Because even a justified idea can be overshadowed by the way it is expressed.
But similarly, critics lose their power if they take words out of context.
This standard applies to both sides.
The value of criticism lies not in the volume of its voice but in the strength of its reasoning.
It’s Sunday… This Is My Piece!
A person’s existence need not be dedicated to a nation.
True.
But the relationship a person forms with the society they grow up in is not merely a legal obligation.
There is belonging.
There is memory.
There is loyalty.
And of course, the individual has the right to agency over their own life.
We do not have to set these against each other.
Greatness is not in self-glorification…
But in not forgetting where you came from.
And remember…
Do not underestimate this nation’s memory by looking only at its wallet.
Because if a person tries to rise by belittling where they came from…
They may also shadow their own dignity.
My final word is not only for an artist, a statement, or a debate.
It is for everyone who tries to define this country’s people solely by their economic hardships, political choices, or social media reactions…
You can read a nation’s wallet.
But without reading its memory, you cannot understand it.
And a person’s true greatness is measured not only by how far they rise…
But by whether they forget where they came from as they rise.



