While the number of valid votes in Muğla increased by 4,216 in the party leadership primary, Datça’s increase was limited to just 36. Yet, in the October 18 district chairmanship race, Nail Kızıl’s 462-vote lead over his rival in Datça accounted for roughly 40% of the total reported margin across the province. What does this disparity between the two ballot boxes reveal?
Datça’s decisive role in Nail Kızıl’s election—where was it this time?
In the October 18 district chairmanship primary between Nail Kızıl and Süleyman Girgin, Datça contributed 618 valid votes, 540 of which went to Kızıl. His 462-vote advantage there represented about 40% of the 1,164-vote lead reported across Muğla.
Only 21 days later, the ballot box was set up for the party’s general leadership primary. While the number of valid votes rose in 12 of Muğla’s districts, Datça’s increase was limited to just 36 votes.
So why did Datça, which played a significant role in Nail Kızıl’s victory, not show a comparable rise in participation in the general leadership primary?
Is this difference due to the influence of local organization, the differing competitive dynamics of the two elections, or members’ choices about whether to vote?
Is Datça’s 36-vote increase merely a statistical footnote, or a question local politics must address?
Recall | We previously analyzed Datça’s weight at the ballot box on October 18 →
Keyifli Datça had examined in detail how Nail Kızıl’s votes from Datça influenced the overall results in Muğla’s district chairmanship race. To understand today’s picture, it’s worth revisiting that report.
Previous analysis: When Candidates Faced Their Members: What Really Changed as Nail Kızıl Was Tested by the New System?
Ballot box growth in Muğla—what happened in Datça?
In the November 8 YENİ Party general leadership primary, the total valid votes across Muğla rose from 16,314 to 20,530—a 4,216 vote increase, or 25.84%.
Bodrum saw a 74.29% increase, Marmaris 53.05%, and Dalaman 33.39%. Valid votes rose in 12 of Muğla’s 13 districts; only Kavaklıdere experienced a decline.
And Datça?
Datça had 618 valid votes on October 18, which rose to 654 on November 8—an increase of just 36 votes.
Why did Muğla’s overall valid vote count rise by 25.84%, while Datça’s increase was only 5.83%?
What makes this disparity more notable is Datça’s previous position.
Datça, where Nail Kızıl secured a 462-vote lead over Süleyman Girgin in the district chairmanship race, held significant weight in terms of vote difference among candidates. Yet in the general leadership primary, Datça ranked 11th out of 13 districts in terms of valid vote growth.
It’s important to distinguish two facts here: the votes Nail Kızıl received and the total vote increase in the general leadership primary are not the same. We also do not know if members who voted in the previous election chose not to vote this time.
Still, this is a difference worth explaining.
Three ballot boxes, three different Datças
On September 26, 350 members voted in the Datça district chairmanship primary, where Ege Curacı was the sole candidate.
On October 18, 618 valid votes were recorded in the district chairmanship primary contested by Nail Kızıl and Süleyman Girgin.
On November 8, the general leadership primary saw 654 valid votes.
Three elections, three different levels of participation.
These figures alone do not explain why members voted or abstained. Examining voter lists, candidate numbers, and election conditions together is necessary.
Here, a key question arises about YENİ Party’s direct member election model:
What motivates members to vote—is it simply having the right to vote, or believing they can make a meaningful choice at the ballot box?
In Datça, answers to this question should come not only from the central party but also from local organization leaders.
Because explaining an election result is one thing; explaining the reasons behind it is another.
Is the increase at the ballot box a measure of loyalty to the leader?
The 4,216-vote increase in Muğla following the general leadership primary is interpreted as an indicator of interest in Özgür Özel.
However, one detail should not be overlooked.
On October 18, Nail Kızıl and Süleyman Girgin were two candidates facing members. On November 8, Özgür Özel was the sole candidate in the general leadership primary.
Thus, in one election members chose between two names; in the other, they voted with only one candidate on the ballot.
Can we directly infer political loyalty by comparing valid vote counts from these two elections?
Going to the ballot box may be a choice. But the reasons behind that choice could include support for the leader, party solidarity, organizational calls, or simply the desire to participate.
Without understanding which factor was decisive, it is impossible to explain members’ political views solely by looking at vote count increases.
Who will explain Datça’s 36-vote increase?
Attention now turns to the Datça organization.
Given Datça’s notable vote distribution in the October 18 district chairmanship race, the fact that its increase on November 8 lagged behind Muğla’s average deserves explanation.
How many members were eligible to vote in each election? Did the number of ballot boxes or voting conditions change? What methods were used in member outreach and election campaigns?
Answers to these questions could clarify not only Datça’s 36-vote difference but also how YENİ Party’s direct member election model functions in practice.
Because assessing a party’s democratic participation claim requires not only that ballots are held, but also that results are transparent and accountable.
As Keyifli Datça, we ask: Has the cause of this disparity in Datça been investigated? If so, will the findings be shared with members and the public?
The ballot box is closed, but questions remain
YENİ Party’s primaries in Muğla have concluded. The district chair has been chosen, the general leadership vote held, and results announced.
Yet election results show more than just winners and vote counts. Sometimes they prompt us to question why one district behaves differently from others.
In Datça, votes did not decline. On the contrary, they increased by 36. But this rise was far below that seen in many other Muğla districts.
We do not know the reasons for this difference. Without explanations about members’ choices, election conditions, and organizational efforts, reaching a definitive political conclusion is not possible.
But one thing is clear:
The votes cast have been counted. Now it is time to explain what those numbers mean.
THREE ELECTIONS, THREE BALLOT BOXES IN DATÇA
2026 • Number of votes recorded in each election
Vote Increase from October 18 to November 8
Note: September 26 data shows the number of members who voted; October 18 and November 8 data show valid votes. Increase rates are calculated between the last two elections.
.kd-secim-2026 { width: 100%; max-width: 100%; box-sizing: border-box; font-family: inherit; color: #20232a; } .kd-secim-2026 * { box-sizing: border-box; } .kd-secim-2026 h3 { margin: 0 0 8px; font-size: 23px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-alt { margin-bottom: 18px; color: #555; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-ozet { background: #f5f5f5; padding: 18px; border-radius: 8px; margin-bottom: 20px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-ozet p { margin: 0 0 8px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-ozet p:last-child { margin-bottom: 0; } .kd-secim-2026 table { width: 100%; border-collapse: collapse; font-size: 14px; table-layout: fixed; } .kd-secim-2026 th, .kd-secim-2026 td { padding: 11px 7px; border-bottom: 1px solid #e5e5e5; text-align: right; overflow-wrap: anywhere; } .kd-secim-2026 th:first-child, .kd-secim-2026 td:first-child { text-align: left; } .kd-secim-2026 thead { background: #20232a; color: white; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-datca { background: #fff0f7; font-weight: 700; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-toplam { background: #eeeeee; font-weight: 700; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-mobil { display: none; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-not { font-size: 12px; color: #666; margin-top: 14px; } @media (max-width: 700px) { .kd-secim-2026 .kd-masaustu { display: none; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-mobil { display: block; } .kd-secim-2026 h3 { font-size: 20px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-kart { border: 1px solid #e3e3e3; border-radius: 9px; padding: 13px; margin-bottom: 10px; min-width: 0; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-kart h4 { margin: 0 0 10px; font-size: 17px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-kart-grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 10px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-kart-grid span { display: block; font-size: 11px; color: #666; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-kart-grid strong { display: block; font-size: 16px; margin-top: 3px; } .kd-secim-2026 .kd-datca { border-color: #fe019a; } }
MUĞLA PRIMARY ELECTION RESULTS
District Chairmanship – General Leadership Comparison
District Chairmanship: October 18, 2026 — 16,314 valid votes
General Leadership: November 8, 2026 — 20,530 valid votes
Muğla overall: +4,216 votes (+25.84%)
Districts: Increase in 12 districts, decrease in 1 district
Datça: +36 votes (+5.83%)
| District | October 18 | November 8 | Difference | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bodrum | 2,365 | 4,122 | +1,757 | +74.29% |
| Marmaris | 1,146 | 1,754 | +608 | +53.05% |
| Dalaman | 542 | 723 | +181 | +33.39% |
| Seydikemer | 470 | 620 | +150 | +31.91% |
| Ula | 544 | 695 | +151 | +27.76% |
| Yatağan | 1,430 | 1,777 | +347 | +24.27% |
| Köyceğiz | 781 | 942 | +161 | +20.61% |
| Milas | 1,541 | 1,813 | +272 | +17.65% |
| Fethiye | 2,492 | 2,765 | +273 | +10.96% |
| Menteşe | 2,969 | 3,288 | +319 | +10.74% |
| DATÇA | 618 | 654 | +36 | +5.83% |
| Ortaca | 1,083 | 1,121 | +38 | +3.51% |
| Kavaklıdere | 333 | 256 | −77 | −23.12% |
| MUĞLA | 16,314 | 20,530 | +4,216 | +25.84% |
MUĞLA OVERALL
DATÇA
Note: Comparison is based on valid vote counts and does not reflect voter turnout rates. Data should be verified against official election records before publication.
${d[0]}





